Search
Close this search box.

Pennsylvania court rules ‘unlicensed driver exclusion’ runs counter to state law

ruck (6)

Pennsylvania court rules ‘unlicensed driver exclusion’ runs counter to state law

The opinion held that the coverage exclusion in Nationwide’s policy went against the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court has held that Nationwide‘s exclusion barring recovery for injured unlicensed drivers runs counter to Pennsylvania law.

The opinion, authored by President Judge Jack Panella, held that the coverage exclusion in Nationwide’s policy, which says unlicensed drivers cannot be covered, went against the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law (MVFRL), which requires insurers to provide first-party medical expense coverage for motor vehicle-related injuries.

According to Panella, Christina Tapia Castaneda was driving her mother’s car without a valid driver’s license when she was rear-ended by another car, causing her to suffer severe injuries. As Castaneda’s mother had a Nationwide insurance policy covering the car, Castaneda submitted a claim for first-party medical expense benefits.

However, Nationwide claimed it had no duty to cover her medical expenses under the unlicensed driver exclusion in the policy and went on to seek a declaration that it wasn’t obligated to pay first-party medical benefits to Castaneda under the exclusion. The trial court agreed and issued judgment in favor of Nationwide.

On appeal, Castaneda argued that the MVFRL “mandates that policyholders pursue, and insurers provide coverage for, first-party medical expenses for injuries arising from the use of a motor vehicle,” with the General Assembly having “made clear its language in Section 1711 that its intent was undoubtedly to require policyholders to purchase a minimum amount of medical expense coverage for injuries stemming from the use of motor vehicles, while at the same time requiring insurers to cover that amount should a first-party claim for medical expenses be submitted.”

Complex Claims & Litigation Forum 2024EVENT

The conference experience aimed to help insurers and litigators Prevent, Prepare, and Prevail in complex claims cases and risks.

Get More Information

The Superior Court agreed, noting that carriers must pay regardless of fault. The court further credited Castaneda’s argument that mandatory no-fault first-party medical expense coverage “has historically been an inviolate part of Pennsylvania’s auto insurance coverage scheme.”

According to Panella, in making medical expense coverage mandatory in the MVFRL, the General Assembly made the decision to treat it differently from other first-party benefit coverage.

“To be sure, there are no other first-party benefits, other than medical expense coverage, listed as a required benefit in Section 1711. Instead, the following section of the MVFRL, Section 1712, entitled ‘Availability of benefits,’ lists other first-party benefits related to injury arising out of the use of a motor vehicle that an insurer does not have to provide coverage for but instead, must make available for policyholders to purchase if they so choose,” Panella said. “Those optional benefits include income loss benefits, accidental death benefits and funeral benefits.”

According to Panella the issue came down to whether Section 1718 represented a finite set of permissible exclusions, which is what Castaneda claims, or whether, per Nationwide’s argument, the section doesn’t “represent an exhaustive list of exclusions insurers may invoke to deny a claim for mandatory medical expense benefits.”

Panella agreed with Castaneda’s argument that the court couldn’t ignore the mandatory nature of medical expense coverage because doing so would ignore the legislature’s intent for insurers to provide a minimum amount of medical expense coverage for injuries sustained in a car accident.

“In Section 1718, the legislature set out a list of ‘limited circumstances where an insurer may exclude persons from the benefits of this mandatory no-fault medical expense coverage,’” wrote Panella.

“Section 1718 does not include an unlicensed driver exclusion, and therefore it is not a valid exclusion upon which Nationwide can rely to refuse coverage for Christina’s medical expenses arising from the accident,” Panella concluded. “We stress that our conclusion is confined to claims for first-party medical expense benefits, the only benefits at issue in this case.”

Castaneda’s attorney, Scott B. Cooper of Schmidt Kramer, said he and his co-counsel, James C. Haggerty of Haggerty, Goldberg, Schleifer & Kupersmith, were pleased that the court followed the Pennsylvania MVFRL.

“Hopefully, the insurance companies will realize that the courts are not going to let them decide what motor vehicle insurance they want and do not want to provide to its insured,” said Cooper. “The law sets the standard and when the company narrows and conflicts with the law the provision will be deemed invalid.”

Nationwide’s attorney, Matthew M. Haar of Saul Ewing Arnstein & Lehr, did not immediately return a request for comment.

Insurance Coverage Law Center editor’s note: Castaneda may have been driving without a license, but she was driving her mother’s car with her mother’s permission. Since she was driving the insured vehicle with the permission of the named insured, she came within the scope of the Nationwide policy.

Financial responsibility laws exist to ensure that people are protected from loss due to auto accidents. While insurers are allowed to create policy language and exclusions, the specific issue here, that of first-party medical expenses and an unlicensed driver who was injured, is unique in that the policy exclusion is contrary to state law. Notice that the court made clear that the position only applies to first-party medical expenses; had the unlicensed driver injured another party, the exclusion would have been upheld.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

Risk Management

Mitigating Financial Losses During Hurricane Season: A Skyscraper Insurance Guide

As hurricane season approaches, businesses must take proactive steps to safeguard against financial losses. At Skyscraper Insurance, we understand the unique challenges companies face in times of disaster, and we’re committed to helping our clients navigate them successfully. Here’s how your business can mitigate financial risks with the right strategies and support. 1. Diversifying Income Streams for Resilience A diversified revenue model is crucial to withstanding the disruptions caused by hurricanes. Skyscraper Insurance works with businesses to evaluate new opportunities—whether it’s launching an online platform, expanding services, or entering new markets. This ensures that if one revenue stream is impacted, others can sustain the business. 2. Comprehensive Insurance Coverage The first line of defense is making sure your insurance policies are up to date and cover potential hurricane-related damages. Skyscraper Insurance specializes in providing tailored insurance solutions, including business interruption coverage, property damage, and flood insurance, to protect our clients against catastrophic financial losses. 3. Creating a Contingency Plan with Experts In partnership with Skyscraper Insurance, businesses can develop disaster contingency plans that ensure operations continue smoothly, even in the face of supply chain delays or power outages. We help you establish backup solutions, such as alternate suppliers or inventory management systems, minimizing financial fallout. 4. Maintaining a Recovery Fund Skyscraper Insurance advises its clients to maintain a recovery fund, ensuring fast access to resources for repairs, inventory restocking, and other unforeseen costs. This proactive approach enables businesses to get back on their feet quickly without waiting for loans or insurance claims to process. 5. Leveraging Government Aid and Local Resources In the aftermath of a hurricane, government aid can be crucial for businesses. We assist our clients in navigating grants, low-interest loans, and tax breaks available through local and federal disaster relief programs, ensuring that financial recovery is swift. 6. Risk Management Strategies At Skyscraper Insurance, we provide businesses with customized risk management strategies designed to reduce vulnerabilities and protect financial stability. From evaluating potential hazards to implementing risk-transfer solutions, we help you mitigate loss before a disaster strikes. 7. Ensuring Proper Documentation for Claims Keeping detailed financial records is essential for filing accurate and timely insurance claims. We help clients organize and maintain critical documents that streamline the claims process, ensuring a quicker recovery period. Skyscraper Insurance: Your Partner in Resilience While hurricanes can be unpredictable, your business doesn’t have to face them alone. At Skyscraper Insurance, our commitment goes beyond coverage; we provide expert guidance and comprehensive risk management services that empower businesses to stay strong and resilient during hurricane season.

Read More
Safety Tips

How Natural Disasters Impact Supply Chains: Lessons from Hurricanes

Natural disasters like hurricanes wreak havoc on supply chains, causing major disruptions that can affect business operations for weeks or even months. For businesses, it’s critical to understand how these disruptions occur and to take steps to mitigate them. At Skyscraper Insurance, we help our clients navigate these challenges with smart risk management strategies that protect their bottom line. Here’s how hurricanes impact supply chains and what businesses can do to prepare. The Impact of Hurricanes on Supply Chains Hurricanes affect supply chains in several key ways: Minimizing the Impact: Strategies for Business Resilience While hurricanes are unpredictable, businesses can minimize their impact on supply chains through proactive planning: Inventory and Distribution Strategies Hurricanes often lead to localized supply shortages in the regions directly affected, but businesses that rely on global supply chains must also be wary of broader impacts. Global markets can feel the ripple effects as businesses look for alternative suppliers or routes, which might drive up costs and delay deliveries. Supporting Employees and Customers Beyond the logistical impact, hurricanes also bring safety risks to employees and customers. Ensure that safety plans are in place, including clear evacuation procedures and communication strategies. For employees working in distribution or warehouses, it’s essential to prioritize their well-being by closing operations in unsafe conditions and providing post-storm recovery support. Final Thoughts Supply chains are the backbone of many businesses, but they are also vulnerable to the unpredictable forces of nature. By diversifying suppliers, investing in technology, and planning ahead, businesses can minimize the disruption caused by hurricanes and other natural disasters. At Skyscraper Insurance, we’re here to help our clients protect their supply chains and navigate the challenges posed by these extreme events.

Read More
Try your instant quote