Parametric insurance is reshaping commercial property coverage

A shift to non-traditional solutions: Parametric insurance provides an increasingly compelling alternative.

The commercial-property insurance landscape is undergoing a notable evolution, marked by a discernible shift toward non-traditional solutions.

As alternative products gain traction and bridge the gaps left by traditional coverage, one innovative approach stands out: Parametric insurance.

Also known as index-based insurance, parametric insurance policies have most frequently been implemented in developing economies. They’re also gaining momentum among U.S. businesses in disaster-prone areas.

This paradigmatic shift is not merely an adaptation to changing times; it’s a pivotal reimagining of how businesses protect their assets in the face of unpredictable risks.

The rise of parametric insurance

Unlike traditional indemnity-based insurance, which assesses losses after they occur, parametric insurance operates on predefined parameters such as wind speeds, earthquake magnitudes or rainfall levels. It functions on the principle of triggers: When a predefined event occurs, such as a certain level of seismic activity or a specified wind speed, policyholders receive a predetermined payout.

One of the defining features of parametric insurance is its ability to provide swift payouts. Traditional insurance often involves lengthy claims processes, evaluations and negotiations, causing funding delays for the affected businesses. Conversely, parametric insurance eliminates much of this bureaucracy. Since payouts are triggered by predefined events, there’s less ambiguity in assessing the damage, leading to faster disbursement of funds. This rapid injection of capital can be instrumental in facilitating quick recovery, allowing businesses to resume operations and minimize downtime, ultimately reducing the overall financial impact of the incident.

Moreover, this innovative approach offers a level of customization that traditional insurance struggles to match. Businesses can tailor their coverage precisely to their needs, selecting triggers and parameters that align with their specific vulnerabilities.

For instance, a coastal business might opt for a parametric insurance policy linked to hurricane wind speeds, ensuring they receive compensation immediately after a storm hits, regardless of the actual damage incurred. This flexible, tailored approach empowers businesses to proactively mitigate risks that are most pertinent to their operations and allows for more efficient use of insurance resources, avoiding unnecessary premiums on non-relevant risks.

Another advantage of parametric insurance is its transparency. The triggers and parameters are explicitly defined in the policy, leaving little room for disputes over whether a claim qualifies for compensation. This transparency fosters trust between insurers and policyholders, a crucial aspect in an industry where clarity and reliability are paramount.

Understanding parametric insurance pitfalls

Though businesses, especially those vulnerable to specific perils like natural disasters or market fluctuations, are recognizing the appeal of this innovative approach, parametric insurance isn’t without risks. The predetermined nature of payouts means that they might not fully align with the actual losses incurred. There could be scenarios where the triggered event doesn’t directly correlate with the actual financial impact, leaving businesses with a shortfall in coverage.

Another pitfall to consider is basis risk, where the triggering event might occur but fail to meet the predefined parameters for payout. This discrepancy between the defined triggers and the actual impact could leave businesses without the anticipated financial support precisely when they need it most.

Parametric insurance and the future of coverage

Looking ahead, the future of commercial property insurance appears increasingly intertwined with non-traditional approaches like parametric insurance. As technology advances and data analytics become more sophisticated, parametric insurance will likely become more precise, reducing basis risks and refining its ability to provide prompt, tailored coverage. However, it’s still important for policyholders to understand its nuances and limitations.

Nevertheless, while parametric insurance represents just one facet of the evolving landscape, it’s a compelling alternative to traditional indemnity-based insurance for businesses looking for an agile, proactive way to protect their assets in an increasingly unpredictable world.

Mark Pennebaker is senior vice president and Commercial Lines practice leader at Foundation Risk Partners. These opinions are the author’s own.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Commercial P&C Insurance

Commercial Office Space Set for a Strong Comeback

The sustained increase in demand for office space across the nation since late 2022 suggests that the market has moved past its lowest point, according to insights from the real estate technology platform, VTS. Demand for office space began to rise in late 2022 and continued into early 2023. Since then, the office market has experienced a period of stability and growth, supported by favorable economic factors, indicating a market rebound. This conclusion is drawn from the VTS Office Demand Index (VODI), which tracks unique new tenant tour requests for office properties in key U.S. markets. The VODI serves as an early indicator of future office leasing activity. According to the index, demand for office space has grown consistently over the past 12 months, closing the second quarter with a 17% year-over-year increase and a 34% rise from the VODI’s lowest point in December 2022. A significant shift in office-based employment patterns further supports the belief that demand for office space has stabilized. After reaching its peak in August 2022, office-based employment declined by 3.9% in early 2024. However, this trend has since stabilized, and employment growth has remained steady. Additionally, a recent decrease in work-from-home rates has fueled the renewed demand for office space. “They say you can only recognize a market bottom after it has passed, and the office space market is no exception. Following what we now see as the bottom, the national demand has gradually increased, though it remains susceptible to economic challenges,” said Nick Romito, CEO of VTS. “However, the growth observed in VODI over the past 18 months, coupled with positive trends in the office-using workforce, suggests that the market has reset, and the worst is behind us.” It’s important to note that this national trend does not impact all local markets equally. Cities like Los Angeles and New York City have seen healthy growth in office space demand, while markets such as San Francisco and Washington, D.C., have experienced prolonged stagnation. In Los Angeles, office space demand surged in the second quarter, briefly surpassing pre-COVID levels, driven by an increase in the average size of office spaces sought by tenants. New York City followed a similar overall pattern, though with some softness in the second quarter. Conversely, San Francisco’s demand for office space remains unpredictable, largely due to its tech-focused workforce, which continues to favor remote work more than other industries. “Markets heavily dependent on the tech sector, like San Francisco and Seattle, are on a markedly different post-COVID recovery path compared to more diversified markets like Los Angeles and New York City. It may take some time before we see office demand in San Francisco and Seattle return to pre-COVID levels,” added Ryan Masiello, Chief Strategy Officer at VTS.

Cyber Liability

Global IT Outage Puts Business Interruption Insurance in the Spotlight

In July, a global IT outage had a significant impact on business interruption insurance policies, overshadowing the effects on cyber insurance coverages. “This incident wasn’t a result of a malicious attack, which is why typical cyber insurance policies may not have been activated,” explained Peter McMurtrie, a partner in West Monroe’s insurance sector, in an interview with PropertyCasualty360.com. “Where coverage was applicable, factors like deductible amounts, waiting periods, and coverage limits played a critical role in determining the extent of exposure,” McMurtrie noted. “Standard policies for small businesses were less likely to offer coverage, while more complex policies for mid-sized companies and Fortune 500 corporations may have included broader triggers for non-malicious outages caused by third-party software issues.” The outage was triggered by a software update on July 19, 2024, by cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike, which affected organizations worldwide using Microsoft Windows. This interruption had far-reaching consequences, including disrupting hospital systems, media outlets, financial institutions, delaying thousands of flights, and halting daily business operations. McMurtrie emphasized that while the initial impact of the outage was similar for both large and small businesses, the ability to recover operations and whether insurance covered the loss of business income varied. “Larger companies are more likely to have advanced disaster recovery plans that ensure service redundancy following unexpected outages,” he added. “Their insurance programs also tend to cover a wider range of incidents.” According to Microsoft, the CrowdStrike update error affected over 8.5 million Windows devices globally. The incident highlighted the interconnected nature of our global ecosystem, including cloud providers, software platforms, security services, and their clients. “It’s a stark reminder of the importance of prioritizing safe deployment and disaster recovery across the tech industry,” the company said in a blog post. McMurtrie pointed out that the outage’s widespread impact was largely due to its effect on organizations that are critical to societal infrastructure—sectors like agriculture, airlines, banking, energy, government, healthcare, manufacturing, and retail. “Insurance companies base their risk appetite on their ability to understand and price risks appropriately. This becomes increasingly challenging with emerging threats,” he said. “However, I anticipate that insurers will respond by clarifying policy language, refining risk selection criteria, and possibly developing new products specifically designed for this evolving exposure.”

Parametric insurance is reshaping commercial property coverage